Most of this is knowable in advance. We go through the structure for the exposures in your current structure — Form 5472, ECI classification, permanent establishment, withholding routing, BPT, FBAR/FATCA — and rank them by remediation urgency.
Form 5472 penalty
$25,000
Minimum penalty for each year a required Form 5472 is not filed.
Withholding at source rules
30%
Withheld at source on U.S.-source FDAP paid to a foreign person, absent a documented treaty claim.
U.S. corporate tax rate
21%
Federal corporate rate once income is effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business.
FBAR penalty (non-wilful)
$10,000
Statutory maximum non-willful FBAR penalty per annual report, adjusted annually for inflation.
Figures set by U.S. tax law · Not results from any engagement
§02Exposure Vectors
Six categories. Most founders carry at least three.
EXP.01
▲ CRITICAL
Foreign-owner disclosure rules
Foreign-owned single-member LLCs are disregarded entities that the IRS ignores for most tax purposes, but still treats as a corporation for this one reporting rule. Most founders never learn it exists until the penalty notice arrives.
Exposure
$25,000 minimum
EXP.02
▲ CRITICAL
U.S. trade or business rules
Effectively Connected Income Trigger
Income reclassified from FDAP to ECI is taxed at corporate rates after deduction allowance, with retroactive interest accrual. The classification turns on dependent agency, fixed place of business, and continuity tests.
Exposure
Graduated corporate rates + interest
EXP.03
▲ HIGH
Tax treaty — taxable presence
Permanent Establishment Risk
A single dependent contractor, a leased fulfillment slot, an over-engaged independent agent — each can create permanent establishment sufficient to overcome treaty protection.
Exposure
Full U.S. taxation of business profits
EXP.04
▲ HIGH
Withholding at source rules
Default 30% FDAP Withholding
In the absence of a properly documented treaty claim, all U.S.-source FDAP income to foreign persons is withheld at 30% by the payor. Most founders discover this when Stripe or AdSense remits 70% of expected revenue.
Exposure
30% withheld at source
EXP.05
▲ MEDIUM
Branch profits tax
Branch Profits Tax
Foreign corporations operating via U.S. branch are subject to BPT on the dividend equivalent amount in addition to standard corporate tax. Treaty reductions apply but are jurisdiction-specific.
Exposure
30% on dividend-equivalent amount
EXP.06
▲ HIGH
Foreign account reporting
FBAR / FATCA Disclosure Failure
U.S. founders with foreign accounts, foreign-resident citizens, and dual-status filers face automatic disclosure obligations. In Bittner v. United States, 598 U.S. 85 (2023), the Supreme Court held that the non-willful FBAR penalty attaches to each annual report — not to each unreported account.
Exposure
$10,000 per annual report
§03ECI & Exposure Dossiers